Login
Support Sailonline
If you haven't already  join the SAILONLINE YACHT CLUB!
Please also consider making a donation  all amounts are greatly appreciated!
Page: First Previous 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Next Last
Posted by kroppyer 

I've run some more tests, and sometimes the models predict a value that is so close to the actual one that it's scary, I've seen a difference of 0.000000004 (I might have missed a zero).
Looking at my results, I think we have (almost) unravelled the performance recovery model: new_perf = min(100, old_perf + delta_time*3/(20*abs(boatspeed))) > new_perf and old_perf in % > boatspeed is actual boatspeed (not boatspeed when perf would be 100%) from previous "server jump" in knots > delta_time: time since previous "server jump", in seconds > abs(x) makes x positive > min(x, y) returns the smallest value of x and y. This formula basically translates to "Your performance will increase with 9/boatspeed% per minute, until you reach 100%" The performance loss model that matches the actual values the best, is really close, but no perfect match: if(tack or gybe and old_perf >= 93) new_perf = old_perf * (1  abs(boatspeed)/200) else if(normal course change and old_perf >= 93) new_perf = old_perf * (1  dTWA/25) end if > new_perf and old_perf in % > boatspeed in knots > dTWA is the positive difference between TWA before and after the course change, in radians (1 radian = 180/pi degrees) I think the last thing to unravel is what boatspeed to use in the calculation for performance loss while taking/gybing. > new boatspeed if perf would be 100% > old boatspeed if perf would be 100% > new boatspeed if perf would be the the same as before the tack > old actual boatspeed (with performance the same as before the tack) And there's another thing to do with performance loss that I we haven't tried yet: bbq'ing, I'm not sure why we would want to know the exact performance loss after a bbq, but why not? Attached: > Image with actual values, and values as predicted by 4 different models:  model 1: use current boatspeed for tack/gybeperf.losscalculation  model 2: use max boatspeed (when perf would be 100%) for tack/gybeperf.losscalculation  model 3: like model 1, but performance loss is directly subtracted from performance (instead of multiplying with the (1  loss) thing.  model 4: like model 2, but same substraction method as in model 3 model 1 fits best. > Raw data, csv file, can be opened with excel 

Posted by javakeda 

Kroppyer wrote:
>>>>>
>>>>> So, just to complete the logic [and make sure that I am following you] ... If the code falls through the IFs above, we are left with: new_perf = min(100, old_perf + delta_time*3/(20*abs(boatspeed))) And that implements the 93% rule? Can you determine from the data whether the "recovery" code executes before, after, or instead of the "course change" code? Thank you for your work on this. 

Posted by Go4iT 

Looks like it is about time for the SOL developers to change the performance loss parameters! hehehe


Posted by Rod 

Why? It wasn't supposed to be a secret, was it? However, it does seem somewhat complicated, unless it was derived from actual data gathered from IRL boats. I would question, however the perf loss from a gybe,, which seems too great, UNLESS it involves dropping and rehoisting a spinnacker. And a mere change of course should not involve a perf loss of any great amount. The rudder is still a good brake, however!
I am going to attempt to reduce the math to two readyreference graphs, one showing perf loss at any angle and windspeed, the other showing expected recovery and time to add to any DC to compensate for the loss in distance travelled. If it breaks, it's not strong enoughif it doesn't, it's too heavy. 

Posted by A2 

Why Rod ? Why Indeed !
The Rationale for this hindrance has been expounded on in the previously linked thread. Wrong Speed VMG Posted by Jakob Kuttenkeuler 20090212 "We introduced this performance loss not to punish normal sailing maneouvers but to prevent boats to tack e.g. once every minute during hours just to ride on a tws that optimizes vmg. The performance loss implementation succeeded in preventing that behavior and is as stated above not a problem for normal maneouvers." But please don't let me stop anyone from actually going to the source material and reading it for themselves as there are even more useful tidbits to be gleaned should one choose to do so. There is merit in spending an equal amount of time reading these Forums as is devoted to contributing in them. None so blind 

Posted by javakeda 

A2R: Thanks for the link to that thread.
To think that the PERF formulas have been sitting on the forum since 2009! Ya think we need a search function for this puppy? Or, as you suggested, ya think we need to RTFF? (Note: Those who know me as an avid fan of MAD Magazine will recognize that the first 'F' in the acronym above stands for 'Furshlugginer'.) 

Posted by A2 

NSA recommends using Google for this purpose
site:http://www.sailonline.org/board/ "performance loss" yeilded only only 9 hits when I went looking for it. Today there are 11. Took about all of 20 minutes to find the good stuff. Time well spent considering. None so blind 

Posted by kroppyer 

Performance Recovery
new_perf = min(100, old_perf + delta_time*3/(20*abs(boatspeed))) > new_perf and old_perf in % > boatspeed is actual boatspeed (not boatspeed when performance would be 100%) from previous performance calculation. Speed in knots > delta_time: time since previous performance calculation, in seconds > abs(x) makes x positive > min(x, y) returns the smallest value of x and y. This formula basically translates to "Your performance will increase with 9/boatspeed% per minute, until you reach 100%" Performance loss if(tack or gybe and old_perf >= 93) new_perf = old_perf * (1  abs(boatspeed)/200) else if(normal course change and old_perf >= 93) new_perf = old_perf * (1  dTWA/25) end if > new_perf and old_perf in % > boatspeed is the boat speed after the tack, calculated using the old performance. Speed in knots > dTWA is the positive difference between TWA before and after the course change, in radians (1 radian = 180/pi degrees) I believe performance loss only kick in when a command is executed, or when the boat tacks or gybes (when you are sailing cc trough a windshift, your performance drops when you gybe/tack) I think performance recovery is also active in the "server jump" that performance loss is calculated. But the command to change course can be at the start of the server jump, or at the end, or somewhere in between. I'm not sure what boatspeeds are used how in the recovery formula in the same jump performance loss is calculated. I think we have reach the limit now, the server jumps limit us from being more accurate, and I think it's not really of any use to be able to predict performance more accurate. I will, when I caught up with other things I should've done, implement this performance model in my program spinnacer, so that calculations with performance will be easier to do.  It might be interesting to think of tricks with this model. hmm did his trick with the gybe, but I'm sure there's more:  a 100.3 degree course change will cause 7% performance loss. So when you need to do a sharper turn (without gybing/tacking) you can turn 105 degrees first (perf<93%), and directly after that the rest of the turn (perf does not drop anymore than those 93%)  Performance loss is smaller when your performance is not yet at 100%, but you're faster when you wait for your performance to reach 100% (sailing two times 5 minutes with average performance 98.5% is faster than sailing 10 minutes with an average performance of 97.2%). But what if your perf is lower than 93%, it's of course better to do it at that moment, as it won't do anything with your performance. And then there's an area in between, where part of the perf. loss could be "absorbed" by the 93% rule.  Tacking, and then turning to the right course is extra performance loss, if you tack to the right course in one go, it faster, unless boat speeds differ much.. It's getting complicated..  It in light winds, it might be better to do two tacks/gybes instead of one course change. Since tacking/gybing doesn't result in a big drop in performance when sailing slow, while a course change always has the same performance drop.  etc.. etc.. I think we have unravelled the model and calculations, now comes the hard part: how to use it in our advantage Anyway, with this we can at least do better calculations for DCs/routing 

Posted by Go4iT 

Tried that as a search engine in Google and got '404'. What am I doing wrong?
 Last Edited by Go4iT at 20131015 23:16:35  

Posted by A2 

Go to Google;
In the Search bar site: followed without any space by the url of this board then your search terms after that You can also go to the link at the bottom of the Google search page and click the link that says "Advanced Search" There are boxes there to do the same thing, so when you hit search look at how Google has arranged the same business in the Search bar for you.  Last Edited by A2R at 20131016 00:12:13  None so blind 
Page: First Previous 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Next Last
Please login to post a reply.Races
Next Race: 00d 00h 00m
Current Races:
Up Helly Aa 2023
AOI!!! The cry should soon be ringing out in the streets of Lerwick as the Guizer Jarl and his crew, along with the other teams in the Up Helly Aa parade complete their preparations for the biggest fire festival in Europe. As is Sailonline's tradition, we shall be racing the 383nm from Aberdeen to Lerwick to (virtually) take part in the Up Helly Aa festivities there which take place for the first time since 2020 on Tuesday, 31 January. SAILING NOTE: Gruney may be approached from any direction but must be passed for rounding purposes as indicated on the chart.
Race #1660
INFO by brainaid.de
Elan 410 PARTICULARS
WX Updates:
0430 / 1030 / 1630 / 2230
Ranking: SYC
Race starts: Jan 28th 11:00
Registration Open!
Iceland TIMED Race 2023
Welcome to Iceland, where the weather is chilly but there are plenty of volcanoes and beaches to admire along Iceland's beautiful south coast. In fact, our first TIMED race of this year will take us on a 150nm eastbound trip in quick Orange Cats from the Vestmannaeyjaber archipalego to the Stokksnes peninsula. Just mind to enjoy the view from a distance and avoid the temptation to BBQ on the pristine beaches!
REREGISTER HERE to race again after finishing a run
Race #1650
INFO by brainaid.de
Orange 125 PARTICULARS
WX Updates:
0430 / 1030 / 1630 / 2230
Ranking:
TRQ1  TRCH  SUPSOL  SYC
RACE CLOSE: Sunday, 29 January at 23:00 UTC
Race starts: Jan 14th 12:00
Registration Open!
Sinbad Surveys Arabia 2023
Sinbad AlSOL’er invites you to race him on seven epic voyages (5 to count), not entirely in line with those of his illustrious ancestor AlSail’or described in the 1001 Nights, and totally out of line with those voiced over by Brad Pitt in Sinbad  The Seven Seas, commencing with a survey of Arabia, from the island kingdom of Bahrain all the way to Aqaba, there where, in 1917, after a desperate forced march, TE Lawrence, Sherif Nasir and Auda abu Tayi routed the Ottomans. Instead of camels through the sand, though, we’ll voyage the c 3000nm across the sea on IMOCA 60’s.
Race #1636
INFOby brainaid.de
IMOCA 60 v2 PARTICULARS
WX Updates:
0430 / 1030 / 1630 / 2230
Ranking: SYC  SVS
RACE CLOSE: Tuesday,
January 31 at 2300 UTC.
Race starts: Jan 09th 09:00
Registration Closed
SYC Ranking
Series
 SYC ranking
 2023 TRQ4
 2023 TRQ3
 2023 TRQ2
 2023 TRQ1
 2023 TRCH
 2023 SVS
 2023 SUPerSOLer
 2023 SPRQ4
 2023 SPRQ3
 2023 SPRQ2
 2023 SPRQ1
 2023 SPRCH
 2023 RNI
 2023 OCQ4
 2023 OCQ3
 2023 OCQ2
 2023 OCQ1
 2023 OCCH
 2023 DN
 2023 ARQ4
 2023 ARQ3
 2023 ARQ2
 2023 ARQ1
 2023 ARCH
 2022 TRQ4
 2022 TRQ3
 2022 TRQ2
 2022 TRQ1
 2022 TRCH
 2022 TD
 2022 Tall Ships
 2022 SUPerSOLer
 2022 SSANZ
 2022 SSA
 2022 SPRQ4
 2022 SPRQ3
 2022 SPRQ2
 2022 SPRQ1
 2022 SPRCH
 2022 SHE
 2022 OCQ4
 2022 OCQ3
 2022 OCQ2
 2022 OCQ1
 2022 OCCH
 2022 NTR
 2022 LOOR
 2022 CTR
 2022 ARQ4
 2022 ARQ3
 2022 ARQ2
 2022 ARQ1
 2022 ARCH
 2021 TRQ4
 2021 TRQ3
 2021 TRQ2
 2021 TRQ1
 2021 TRCH
 2021 TD
 2021 Tall Ships
 2021 SYCQ4
 2021 SYCQ3
 2021 SYCQ2
 2021 SYCQ1
 2021 SYCCH
 2021 SUPerSOLer
 2021 SSANZ
 2021 SPRQ4
 2021 SPRQ3
 2021 SPRQ2
 2021 SPRQ1
 2021 SPRCH
 2021 Shetland
 2021 PAC6
 2021 OCQ4
 2021 OCQ3
 2021 OCQ2
 2021 OCQ1
 2021 OCCH
 2021 ESRW
 2020 TSE
 2020 TSA
 2020 TRQ4
 2020 TRQ4
 2020 TRQ3
 2020 TRQ2
 2020 TRQ1
 2020 TRCH
 2020 Tasman Double
 2020 SYCQ4
 2020 SYCQ3
 2020 SYCQ2
 2020 SYCQ1
 2020 SYCCH
 2020 SUPerSOLer
 2020 SSANZ
 2020 SRQ4
 2020 SRQ3
 2020 SRQ2
 2020 SRQ1
 2020 SPRCH
 2020 Shetland
 2020 RTW
 2020 RNI
 2020 Odyssey
 2020 OCQ4
 2020 OCQ3
 2020 OCQ2
 2020 OCQ1
 2020 OCCH
 2020 A3
 2019 TRQ4
 2019 TRQ3
 2019 TRQ2
 2019 TRQ1
 2019 TRCH
 2019 Tasman Double
 2019 Tall Ships
 2019 SYCQ4
 2019 SYCQ3
 2019 SYCQ2
 2019 SYCQ1
 2019 SYCCH
 2019 SUPerSOLer
 2019 SSANZ
 2019 SRQ4
 2019 SRQ3
 2019 SRQ2
 2019 SRQ1
 2019 SPRCH
 2019 Shetland
 2019 Round New Zealand
 2019 OCQ4
 2019 OCQ3
 2019 OCQ2
 2019 OCQ1
 2019 OCCH
 2018 TRQ4
 2018 TRQ3
 2018 TRQ2
 2018 TRQ1
 2018 TRCH
 2018 Tasman Double
 2018 Tall Ships
 2018 SUPSOL
 2018 SSANZ Triple
 2018 SRQ4
 2018 SRQ3
 2018 SRQ2
 2018 SRQ1
 2018 SPRCH
 2018 Shetland
 2018 Shackleton Challenge
 2018 OCQ4
 2018 OCQ3
 2018 OCQ2
 2018 OCQ1
 2018 OCCH
 2018 40CH
 2017 TS RDV
 2017 TRQ4
 2017 TRQ3
 2017 TRQ2
 2017 TRQ1
 2017 TRCH
 2017 Tasman Double
 2017 Tall Ships
 2017 SWR
 2017 SUPSOL
 2017 SSANZ Triple
 2017 SSANZ RNI
 2017 SPRR3
 2017 SPRR2
 2017 SPRR1
 2017 SPRCH
 2017 Red Dot
 2017 OCQ4
 2017 OCQ3
 2017 OCQ2
 2017 OCQ1
 2017 OCCH
 2017 40CQ3&4
 2017 40CQ1&2
 2016 TRQ4
 2016 TRQ3
 2016 TRQ2
 2016 TRQ1
 2016 TRCH
 2016 Tasman Double
 2016 Tall Ships
 2016 SUPSOL
 2016 SSANZ Triple
 2016 SRQ4
 2016 SRQ3
 2016 SRQ2
 2016 SRQ1
 2016 SPRCH
 2016 RTWR
 2016 OCQ4
 2016 OCQ3
 2016 OCQ2
 2016 OCQ1
 2016 OCCH
 2016 Corporate Open Gold
 2016 A3
 2015 TRQ4
 2015 TRQ3
 2015 TRQ2
 2015 TRQ1
 2015 TRCH
 2015 Tasman Double
 2015 Tall Ships
 2015 SYQ4
 2015 SYQ3
 2015 SYQ2
 2015 SYQ1
 2015 SYCCH
 2015 SUPSOL
 2015 SSANZ Triple
 2015 SRQ4
 2015 SRQ3
 2015 SRQ2
 2015 SRQ1
 2015 SPRCH
 2015 OCQ4
 2015 OCQ3
 2015 OCQ2
 2015 OCQ1
 2015 OCCH
 2015 Aegean Rally
 2014 Timed Races Championship
 2014 Tasman Double
 2014 Tall Ships
 2014 SYC Championship
 2014 SSANZ Trio
 2014 SSANZ RNI
 2014 Sprints Championship
 2014 Scandinavian Tour
 2014 Round The World Race
 2014 Ocean Championship
 20142015 Sailonline World Race
 2013 Tall Ships
 2013 SYC Championship
 2013 SSANZ B&G Simrad
 2013 Capt Anderson
 2012 W Australia Regatta
 2012 Tall Ships
 2012 SSANZ B&G Simrad
 2012 RNZ Two Handed
 2012 Global Challenge
 2012 Ecker Cup
 2012 Black Sea
 2012 A3
 2011 Vancouver Island
 2011 Tasman Double
 2011 SSANZ B&G Simrad
 2011 SOL Global Challenge
 2011 SJORA Series
 2011 Scandinavian Tour
 2011 Round North Island
 2011 Asian Sprints
 20112012 SOL World Race
 2010 Tasman Double
 2010 Ouzo Rally
 2010 Iberian Tour
 2010 Auckland Regional
 2009 French SOLo
 2009 Bosphore  Bretagne
 2008 SYCC
 2008 2013 SYC Week Race Championship
 2008 2013 SYC WeekEnd Race Championship
 2008 2013 SYC Ocean Race Championship
 20082009 Sailonline Ocean Race
Mobile Client
SYC members have the benefit of access to our mobile/lightweight web client!